Gelateria Dei Coltelli Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing the Menu at Gelateria Dei Coltelli

Located in Williston Park, Gelateria Dei Coltelli is a delightful destination for dessert lovers. The gelateria’s menu features a diverse selection of gelato flavors, with options constantly rotating to keep things fresh. Customers rave about the rich and distinctive taste of offerings like banana Nutella and salted caramel pretzel—a true flavor explosion.

In addition to their renowned gelato, Gelateria Dei Coltelli also tempts patrons with milkshakes, frozen frappes, and an enticing coffee and espresso bar. Their gelatoccino and iced lattes are fan favorites.

The spacious and modern ambiance invites families and friends to enjoy their creations comfortably, making it an excellent spot for gatherings. With generous portions and friendly service, you’re bound to have a memorable experience that keeps you returning for more!

Milkshakes

Milkshake 16 oz

Please be sure to specify the flavor you would like. To find out our current flavors check our Facebook page or call the store. Flavors change daily.

$9.10

Milkshake 20 oz

Please be sure to specify the flavor you would like. To find out our current flavors check our Facebook page or call the store. Flavors change daily.

$10.40

Iced Latte

16 oz

$5.85

Cold Brew

16 oz

$5.85

Coffee and Espresso Bar

Frozen Frappes

Frozen Nutella Frappe

16 oz

$7.80

Frozen Hot Chocolate Frappe

16 oz

$7.80

Gelatoccino

$10.40

Gelato and Sorbet Cup

$5.20

Gelato and Sorbet Pint

$15.60

Gelato and Sorbet Quart

$28.60

Gelato and Sorbet Nutella Sundae

$10.40

Gelato and Sorbet

Classic Crepes

Nutella Crepe

$13.00

Dulce de Leche Crepe

$13.00

Butter Sugar Crepe

$10.40

Dark Chocolate Crepe

$13.00

Milk Chocolate Crepe

$13.00

White Chocolate Crepe

$13.00

Banana Nutella Crepe

$10.00

Cookie Dough Crepe

$16.25

Dark Chocolate Strawberry Crepe

$16.25

Marshmallow Caramel Crepe

$16.25

S Mores Crepe

Marshmallows, graham crackers, and dark chocolate.

$16.25

Peanut Butter and Jelly Crepe

Strawberry, raspberry, and mix berry or caramel.

$16.25

Butter Cinnamon Sugar Crepe

$11.00

Signature Crepes